BFGoodrich Advantage Control vs Firestone All Season tires

With over 150 years of existence, BFGoodrich is recognized as one of the most reliable American tire manufacturers in the world. Its motorsport-proven durability and precision handling are admired by everyday drivers. From off-road to on-road compatible tires, BFGoodrich lines sport solid tread architectures, optimized compounds, and innovative patterns. The tire manufacturer is now part of the Michelin Group and makes reliable tires for global consumption.

Firestone was founded in 1900 in Akron, Ohio, and is another globally renowned American tire brand that’s known for its high-value tires, solid performance, and wide vehicle compatibility. It now operates under the Bridgestone umbrella and has an exclusive range of tires to meet the demands of drivers in the US and across the world. Its all-season touring tires are highly admired by enthusiasts for their reliable wet grip, impressive highway manners, less noisy drives, and solid year-round traction.

The BFGoodrich Advantage Control is a reliable touring all-season tire that’s designed for use on passenger cars, minivans, and CUVs. It is optimized for great steering response, better braking efficiency, and long-lasting tread life.

On the other hand, we have the Firestone All Season, a dependable, value-offering touring all-season tire to compete against the above tire. The All Season is suitable for use on sedans, coupes, CUVs, and minivans, and has an optimized pattern for improved year-round grip, enhanced ride comfort, and quieter rides.

If you are looking for a reliable set of touring all-season tires, this Advantage Control vs All Season tires comparison will help you choose a better one for your driving needs. Let’s dive deep into the comparison to find out which tire excels in areas like traction, handling, and longevity using our proprietary SimpleScore tire rating system.

Last updated 11/13/2026 - Originally published 11/13/2026

Written by Ankit Verma, Expertly reviewed by Irfan Khan

BFGoodrich Advantage Control tires

First, let’s talk about the BFGoodrich Advantage Control. This tire is made for drivers who look for confident traction and steering response year-round and want something that offers extended service life. It features advanced rubber compounding and has an optimized symmetric tread pattern to provide solid performance and grip in wet and light wintry conditions. It is good at resisting hydroplaning and has adequate lateral stiffness to offer confident cornering along with great ride comfort.

Overall, the Advantage Control earns an impressive 8.8 overall SimpleScore, thanks to its near-perfect longevity, great handling, and admirable year-round traction.

Get BFGoodrich Advantage Control tires at the best deals for your vehicle here

Firestone All Season tires

The Firestone All Season is another great all-season tire that offers seamless touring year-round. Be it rain, shine, or mild winter snow, the All Season ensures quicker steering response and lasting service. Its symmetric tread pattern is tuned for improved biting ability in wet conditions and reduced risk of hydroplaning. Similarly, its wide and flat contact patch is engineered for smooth and quieter commuting.

Overall, the All Season achieves a great 8.4 overall SimpleScore because of its great service life, responsive handling, and solid traction.

Get Firestone All Season tires at the best deals for your vehicle here

BFGoodrich Advantage Control vs Firestone All Season tires on traction

In this section, we will find out which of the two all-season tires is better in traction and offers better road grip year-round. To give you a preview, one of the two tires secured a marginal win over the other to be the winner here.

The Advantage Control earns a solid 8.1 SimpleScore in traction, ensuring confident grip across seasons. The use of a silica-rich rubber compound and Active Sipe Technology contributes to increased grip in wet and mild snowy conditions, while the Aqua-Flume curvilinear channels force water out of the contact patch to prevent hydroplaning and offer solid grip and traction in wet conditions.

Contrarily, the All Season from Firestone achieves an 8.3 SimpleScore in traction, promising better grip year-round. The All Season’s tread pattern features deep, full-tread sipes and wide channel grooves that promote improved surface biting ability and seamless channelling of water from the contact patch. Additionally, the optimized rubber compound of this tire improves contact with the surface for an overall confident grip and great driving experience year-round. In traction, the All Season from Firestone claims victory with a slightly higher SimpleScore.

ADVANTAGE: Firestone All Season

BFGoodrich Advantage Control vs Firestone All Season tires on handling

Next, let’s evaluate the handling performance of both tires to find out which of the two touring all-season tires excels in areas like steering response, braking efficiency, lane changes, and cornering stability.

Starting with the Advantage Control, the tire is rated an 8.6 SimpleScore for its reliable handling and controllability. The g-Wedge Sidewall Stabilizer, along with continuous center ribs, reduces sidewall flex to offer confident lane changing and cornering. The overall flat and durable construction and adequately hard rubber compound provide crisp on-center steering response and impressive highway stability.

On the other hand, the All Season earns an 8.3 SimpleScore in handling. The symmetric tread pattern offers predictable tracking along with vibration absorption. There are deep sipes that contribute to improved braking performance in wet conditions, and the overall design is also optimized to offer seamless lane changes and confident cornering.

In the handling round, it is the Advantage Control that leads with a better rating, equaling 1-1.

ADVANTAGE: BFGoodrich Advantage Control

BFGoodrich Advantage Control vs Firestone All Season tires on longevity

Everyday drivers seek maximum return on investment and want their tires to last longer. Hence, comparing the long-lasting ability becomes important to understand which one would resist wear better.

The Advantage Control surprises with a near-perfect 9.8 SimpleScore in longevity. Likewise, it is also backed by an excellent 75,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, applicable on T- and H-rated sizes, while V- and W-rated sizes are covered by a 65,000 miles tread life warranty. The computer-tuned footprint evenly distributes driving pressures to prevent irregular wear and extends tread life.

Contrarily, the All Season is rated a solid 8.7 SimpleScore in longevity. This tire is covered by a 65,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty for its passenger sizes, while CUV sizes are offered with 55,000 miles warranty. The flat contact patch of this tire prevents irregular wear, whereas the solid rubber compound controls the wear rate for longer use.

In longevity, it is again the BFGoodrich tire that surpasses the Firestone tire’s SimpleScore rating and dominates the comparison (2-1).

ADVANTAGE: BFGoodrich Advantage Control

When to use each

Both the Advantage Control and the All Season are all-season tires and can be considered for driving in dry, wet, and light winter conditions. However, they are not Three Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) certified and shouldn’t be considered for driving in sub-freezing conditions, in temperatures below 45 degrees Fahrenheit. It is also to be noted that both tires are suitable for driving on paved roads and not in off-road conditions.

The Advantage Control is available in 14- to 21-inch rim choices, offering abundant compatibility with vehicles on the market, whereas the All Season comes in 15- to 20-inch sizes.

Which one should you choose?

BFGoodrich Advantage Control vs Firestone All-Season tires side-by-side

Based on overall SimpleScores, the Advantage Control is a better choice than the All Season (8.8 vs 8.4). However, your final decision should depend on your driving style and budget, and your preferences for better traction (All Season) vs. better handling and longevity (Advantage Control).

As far as the prices are concerned, the Advantage Control is available at a starting price of at least $120 per tire, which means a set of four starts at $480. On the other hand, the Firestone All Season is available at a starting price of at least $106 per tire, making a set of four available at $424.

Looking at overall SimpleScore, you must choose the Advantage Control if you:

Drive a vehicle like the Toyota Camry, Nissan Altima, or Honda CR-V.
Need a tire that’s better in longevity (9.8 vs 8.7).
Need a tire that’s better in handling (8.6 vs 8.3).
Need a tire that’s covered by an up to 75,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty.
Need a tire that’s better at stability and braking efficiency (contributed by Aqua-Flume wet-braking technology).
Need a tire that’s slightly expensive but overall better.
Need a tire that’s available in 14- to 21-inch rim sizes.

On the other hand, you should consider the All Season if you:

Drive a vehicle like the Kia Optima, Chevrolet Malibu, and Tesla Model Y.
Want a tire that’s better in traction (8.3 vs 8.1).
Want a tire that’s available in 15- to 20-inch rim sizes.
Want a tire that’s more affordable.

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help, as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.